No title by Stuart G. on Mar 15, 2004 Very overrated, not worth the money. This is a $25 steak that they charge $50 for, and the neighboorhood stinks and the decor is old and... provided bydine.com
Has seen its day by zeecee on Aug 24, 2002 At one time this was a primo steak restaurant, but it now feels like a has-been, overpriced and nowhere near as good as some of the newer places. I'm not sure how many people who live in Manhattan still go to the Old Homestead.... provided bycitysearch.com
No title by RobertK502090 on May 14, 2009 Great food, nice location, a bit tired looking though. Still, cant beat the food... provided byzagat.com
If you don't want a... by A TripAdvisor Contributor on Nov 29, 2007 If you don't want a steak they have really good hamburgers! Nice terrace in the summer,... provided bytripadvisor.com
horrible service very disapointed by micah_disler on Jun 22, 2008 they offered a free dessert in return, we soon asked for compensation for very poor service and got the whole check taken care of. very disapointed! . ... provided bymaps.google.com
No title by buckdapit on Sep 28, 2005 The service was a litlte better in atlantic city than manhattan but thats on the waiter overall people were very nice and when in went to the restrooms on two separate occassions everyone let me go first even if they were... provided bylocal.yahoo.com
No title by Deb M. on Jul 26, 2003 As I stated in one of my other reviews I love steaks. I was very happy to visit this place. The steak was sooooooo good. Cooked just how I liked it. Pleanty of food on your plate too. You will... provided bydine.com
the big burp by steelerman on Aug 8, 2002 the Sherry brothers must get to the butcher district 6 hours after the Luger meat buyers have left. they truly have the worst quality meat of any of the major steakhouses. but if quantity... provided bycitysearch.com
No title by Denise P. on Jan 22, 2001 Very good steak. The location (near the meat packing district)adds to the steak-house charm. Servings abundant, but everything is served a-la-carte,... provided bydine.com
Good Steak, but I'd go elsewhere by dfaccas on Aug 5, 2002 I've had better steaks at the Chicago Chop House, River Palm Terrace (NJ), Bobby Vans, Luger's, Keens, M. Jordan's, Gallagher's, ... Their wine list is narrow and slightly overpriced. Appetizers are pricey, but good. Cooking... provided bycitysearch.com
Some business listings and their related information may have been obtained from third parties, and while we make every effort to assure the accuracy of this information, we do not assume any liability for inaccuracies.
Ratings and review scores are collected from third parties to assist you in your decision making. They do not necessarily reflect our opinions. We take no responsibility for the content, ratings, and reviews from third parties.
